Herring The single most useful thing you can tell a tree surgeon is what is annoying you, not what you want done about it. “The kitchen is dark from two o’clock” leads to a better answer than “take a third off it”, because it lets us suggest the work that actually fixes it — which is quite often less work than you expected, and occasionally a different tree entirely.
This page works through the common complaints and what usually solves each one.
“It Blocks the Light”
The instinct is to reduce the height. The fix is often a crown thin or a crown lift instead.
If the problem is a solid wall of canopy, thinning selectively removes branches throughout the crown so light comes through without changing the tree’s outline. If the problem is that the low branches sit right across a window or a seating area, lifting takes the bottom branches off and leaves the shape alone. Reducing the height only helps where the tree is genuinely casting shade from above — which, given where the sun sits in this country, is less often than people assume.
The relevant guides are crown thinning and crown lifting.
“It Has Got Too Big”
This is where a proper crown reduction belongs. A reduction brings the overall dimensions in while keeping a natural outline, so the tree looks like a smaller version of itself rather than something that has had an accident.
What it is not is topping — cutting the top off straight across. We will not do that. It produces a mass of weak, fast regrowth from the cut ends that is more dangerous in five years than what you started with, and the shape rarely recovers. If a tree is genuinely too big for the space it is in, the honest answer is removal and replanting with something appropriate, not a bad haircut every three years.
“Branches Are on the House / Shed / Car”
Usually the smallest job on this page. Specific branches, targeted, off. It does not need a reduction and it certainly does not need a removal.
Worth doing properly though: cuts back to a growth point or the branch collar rather than random stubs, so the tree responds sensibly rather than throwing out a thicket of new growth in exactly the place you just cleared.
“I Am Worried It Will Fall”
This one deserves a look rather than a decision. Being large is not the same as being unsafe, and a lot of trees that worry their owners are structurally fine.
What we would check is the base and root plate, the main unions where big limbs join the stem, and the crown for dieback or imbalance. Our tree inspection page sets out what that covers and, just as importantly, what it cannot tell you.
If it turns out the tree is sound, that is a good outcome and it costs you a quote visit.
“It Is My Neighbour’s Tree”
The general position, in plain terms: you can cut back growth that crosses your boundary, back to the boundary line and no further. You cannot lean over and prune the rest of their tree, and you cannot go into their garden to do it without permission. What you cut back still belongs to them, so strictly it should be offered back rather than thrown over the fence.
Two things change that picture. A Tree Preservation Order or conservation area status restricts what either of you can do. And cutting hard on one side can unbalance a tree in a way that becomes your problem later, not theirs.
Our honest advice is almost always to knock on the door first. Nearly all of these end reasonably when somebody asks. Very few end reasonably when the first move is a chainsaw.
When the Answer Is Nothing
Worth saying plainly: a fair number of the trees we are called out to look at do not need anything doing to them this year.
A tree that has dropped a few branches in a gale, looks scruffy in March, or has some deadwood in the lower crown is usually just a tree. We would rather tell you that and see you again in three years than sell you work you did not need.
Ready to book Residential Tree Surgery in Nottingham, or still have a question?
Get In Touch →